Reviewer and Editor Guidelines
Sustainexus: Interdisciplinary Research on Sustainability is committed to maintaining a fair, rigorous, transparent, independent, and ethical peer‑review process that upholds internationally recognized standards of scholarly publishing. Reviewers and editors play a fundamental role in ensuring the quality, originality, integrity, and credibility of the interdisciplinary sustainability research published in the journal.
Sustainexus operates a double‑blind peer‑review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers remain confidential throughout the review process. The journal follows the ethical principles and best‑practice recommendations established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and promotes responsible editorial practices, academic independence, and research integrity.
1. Role of Reviewers
Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, subject expertise, research experience, and ability to provide independent and constructive evaluations of submitted manuscripts.
Their primary responsibility is to assess the scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, and scholarly significance of manuscripts while helping authors improve the clarity, reliability, and contribution of their research.
Given the interdisciplinary nature of Sustainexus, reviewers are encouraged to evaluate manuscripts with appropriate consideration of the research objectives, disciplinary context, methodological approach, and contribution to sustainability knowledge.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers are expected to:
- Evaluate manuscripts solely on their scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, significance, clarity, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
- Provide fair, objective, respectful, constructive, and evidence‑based comments that help authors improve their manuscripts.
- Assess whether the research makes a meaningful theoretical, empirical, methodological, practical, or policy contribution to sustainability and sustainable development.
- Evaluate the appropriateness of research design, data collection, analytical techniques, and interpretation of findings.
- Consider the reliability, validity, transparency, and reproducibility of the research where applicable.
- Assess whether the conclusions are adequately supported by the reported evidence.
- Maintain strict confidentiality and treat all submitted manuscripts and supplementary materials as privileged scholarly communications.
- Complete reviews within the requested timeframe or promptly notify the Editorial Office if additional time is required.
- Declare any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting a review invitation.
- Decline review invitations when sufficient subject expertise or impartiality cannot be ensured.
- Identify relevant scholarly literature that may have been overlooked, where appropriate, without requesting unnecessary citations.
- Report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, image manipulation, unethical research practices, citation manipulation, or other publication misconduct.
- Refrain from using unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, professional, or commercial advantage.
- Avoid discriminatory language, personal criticism, unsupported allegations, and inappropriate demands.
Reviewers should provide recommendations based on a balanced assessment of the manuscript rather than personal preferences or competing theoretical perspectives.
Reviewer Recommendations
After completing their assessment, reviewers should provide one of the following recommendations:
- Accept: The manuscript meets the journal's scholarly and editorial standards and requires no substantive revisions.
- Minor Revision: The manuscript is suitable for publication after limited improvements in presentation, interpretation, analysis, or reporting.
- Major Revision: The manuscript demonstrates publication potential but requires substantial improvements in theoretical development, methodology, analysis, discussion, or overall contribution.
- Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements because of fundamental weaknesses in originality, methodological rigor, scholarly contribution, ethical compliance, or relevance to the journal.
Every recommendation should be supported by clear reasoning, specific observations, and constructive suggestions.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final editorial decision rests with the Editor‑in‑Chief or an appropriately delegated editor.
2. Role of Editors
Editors are responsible for maintaining the scholarly quality, ethical integrity, and editorial independence of Sustainexus.
They oversee manuscript evaluation, coordinate peer review, assess reviewer recommendations, and ensure that editorial decisions are fair, transparent, consistent, and based on scholarly merit.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by commercial interests, publication charges, institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, ethnicity, religion, political beliefs, personal relationships, or other irrelevant considerations.
Editorial Responsibilities
Editors are expected to:
- Conduct an initial editorial assessment to determine whether a manuscript falls within the journal's aims and scope and satisfies minimum scholarly and ethical requirements.
- Evaluate the originality, relevance, methodological quality, and potential contribution of submitted research.
- Select qualified and independent reviewers with appropriate disciplinary or interdisciplinary expertise.
- Ensure that manuscripts receive fair and sufficiently rigorous peer review.
- Monitor the review process to maintain reasonable processing times and professional standards.
- Assess reviewer reports critically rather than relying solely on the number or nature of reviewer recommendations.
- Make editorial decisions based on the overall scientific quality, significance, reliability, and ethical compliance of manuscripts.
- Ensure that submissions comply with the journal's publication policies and internationally recognized research‑integrity standards.
- Protect the confidentiality of manuscripts, reviewer identities, editorial communications, and unpublished research.
- Identify and manage conflicts of interest by declining assignments or transferring manuscripts to independent editors when necessary.
- Investigate concerns involving plagiarism, duplicate publication, authorship disputes, citation manipulation, fabricated data, peer‑review manipulation, paper mills, or other research misconduct.
- Address allegations of unethical research practices through fair and evidence‑based procedures.
- Arrange corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions when necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.
- Handle author appeals and complaints impartially and in accordance with established editorial procedures.
- Maintain professional communication with authors, reviewers, and editorial board members.
- Promote scholarly diversity, methodological pluralism, and interdisciplinary collaboration.
The Editor‑in‑Chief retains ultimate responsibility for publication decisions, including decisions delegated to handling editors.
3. Double‑Blind Peer Review
Sustainexus follows a double‑blind peer‑review model to support impartial and independent manuscript evaluation.
Under this system:
- Authors' identities are concealed from reviewers.
- Reviewers' identities are concealed from authors.
- Manuscripts are evaluated according to scholarly quality and relevance.
- Reviewer reports remain confidential unless disclosure is authorized under an applicable journal policy.
- Editorial decisions are based on independent assessment and scholarly evidence.
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are normally assigned to at least two independent reviewers.
Where a manuscript spans multiple disciplines, the handling editor may invite reviewers with complementary expertise to ensure that its theoretical, methodological, and sustainability‑related contributions are adequately assessed.
The journal may seek additional reviews when initial evaluations are inconclusive, contradictory, or insufficiently supported.
4. Confidentiality
Editors and reviewers must maintain strict confidentiality throughout the manuscript evaluation and publication process.
Submitted manuscripts, supplementary materials, research data, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence must be treated as confidential documents.
Editors and reviewers must not:
- Share manuscripts with unauthorized individuals.
- Discuss unpublished findings outside the authorized editorial process.
- Distribute or reproduce confidential materials without permission.
- Use unpublished research findings for personal or professional advantage.
- Upload confidential manuscripts or reviewer reports to unauthorized external platforms.
- Disclose reviewer identities or confidential editorial communications.
Any request to involve another researcher in reviewing a manuscript must receive prior approval from the handling editor.
Confidentiality obligations continue after the completion of peer review, regardless of the final editorial decision.
5. Conflicts of Interest
Editors and reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their professional judgment.
Potential conflicts include:
- Financial interests or commercial relationships.
- Current or recent employment or institutional affiliations.
- Ongoing or recent research collaborations.
- Personal, family, or professional relationships.
- Direct academic competition.
- Involvement in the research being evaluated.
- Financial or professional benefits associated with a publication decision.
Reviewers should decline invitations when conflicts could compromise their independence.
Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where impartiality cannot reasonably be maintained.
Where necessary, manuscripts should be reassigned to an independent editor.
6. Ethical Responsibilities
Editors and reviewers share responsibility for safeguarding research integrity and promoting responsible scholarly publishing.
They should remain attentive to possible concerns involving:
- Plagiarism and inappropriate text reuse.
- Duplicate or redundant publication.
- Fabricated or falsified research data.
- Inappropriate image manipulation.
- Selective or misleading reporting of findings.
- Citation manipulation and coercive citation practices.
- Authorship disputes and inappropriate authorship attribution.
- Missing ethical approval or informed consent.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
- Peer‑review manipulation.
- Paper mill submissions.
- Misrepresentation of research methods or results.
- Fraudulent or misleading AI‑generated content.
- Inadequate disclosure of data limitations or research restrictions.
Suspected misconduct should be reported confidentially to the Editorial Office.
Editors should assess allegations fairly, preserve relevant evidence, provide appropriate opportunities for explanation, and follow applicable COPE guidance.
Reviewers should report concerns without making unsupported accusations directly against authors.
7. Use of Artificial Intelligence
Sustainexus recognizes that artificial intelligence and digital tools may support scholarly communication. However, their use must not compromise confidentiality, research integrity, intellectual independence, or editorial accountability.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, supplementary materials, reviewer reports, or editorial correspondence to public generative AI platforms or unauthorized external services.
AI‑generated reviews must not replace independent expert evaluation.
Reviewers remain personally responsible for the accuracy, originality, fairness, and quality of their assessments.
Responsibilities of Editors
Editors must not use AI systems to make autonomous publication decisions.
AI tools may be used for limited administrative, technical, or language‑support activities only when their use is authorized and complies with confidentiality, data protection, and journal policies.
Any permitted AI‑assisted editorial activity must remain subject to human oversight.
Final editorial judgments and peer‑review assessments must always be made by qualified human experts.
8. Professional Conduct
Editors and reviewers are expected to maintain the highest standards of professionalism, courtesy, fairness, and academic integrity.
All communications should be respectful, constructive, and focused on scholarly matters.
Editors and reviewers must:
- Avoid discriminatory, offensive, or personally derogatory remarks.
- Respect differences in theoretical perspectives, research traditions, and methodological approaches.
- Evaluate research without prejudice toward geographical location, institutional prestige, or researcher background.
- Provide constructive criticism supported by scholarly reasoning.
- Avoid unnecessary delays in manuscript evaluation.
- Maintain accountability and transparency in their assigned responsibilities.
- Respect the intellectual contributions and academic independence of authors.
Sustainexus particularly values the diversity of disciplinary perspectives that contribute to sustainability research.
9. Editorial Independence and Decision‑Making
Sustainexus maintains editorial independence from financial, institutional, commercial, and personal influences.
Manuscript acceptance must be determined exclusively by scholarly quality, ethical compliance, originality, and relevance to the journal.
The journal's open‑access publishing model and Article Processing Charge arrangements must not influence editorial decisions.
Editors must not favor or disadvantage manuscripts based on authors' ability to pay publication fees.
Editorial board members submitting manuscripts to Sustainexus are subject to the same scholarly and ethical standards as other authors.
Such manuscripts must be handled by independent editors without conflicts of interest.
10. Appeals, Complaints, and Editorial Disputes
Sustainexus recognizes the right of authors to raise legitimate concerns regarding editorial decisions and the peer‑review process.
Authors may submit a formal appeal when they believe that:
- A significant factual or methodological error influenced the editorial decision.
- The review process involved a material procedural irregularity.
- A relevant conflict of interest was not appropriately managed.
- The manuscript was evaluated unfairly or inconsistently.
Appeals should provide clear reasoning and supporting evidence.
The Editorial Office will assess appeals fairly and may seek independent editorial advice where necessary.
An appeal does not automatically result in reconsideration or acceptance.
Complaints involving research misconduct, confidentiality, professional behavior, or editorial integrity will be addressed in accordance with applicable journal policies and COPE recommendations.
11. Corrections, Retractions, and Post‑Publication Responsibilities
Editors remain responsible for protecting the integrity of the scholarly record after publication.
When credible concerns arise regarding published articles, the journal may investigate and take appropriate action, including:
- Publishing corrections.
- Issuing expressions of concern.
- Retracting articles where necessary.
- Updating article metadata and publication records.
- Notifying relevant institutions or authorities when justified.
Post‑publication actions should be proportionate, evidence‑based, transparent, and consistent with recognized publication ethics standards.
The journal will seek to preserve the accuracy, accessibility, and integrity of the published scholarly record.
12. Commitment to Excellence
Sustainexus: Interdisciplinary Research on Sustainability recognizes that reviewers and editors are essential partners in maintaining the quality, credibility, and integrity of scholarly communication.
Through independent evaluation, constructive feedback, responsible editorial judgment, and adherence to internationally recognized ethical principles, reviewers and editors contribute to the advancement of reliable and impactful sustainability research.
Sustainexus is committed to fostering a global scholarly community that connects environmental, social, economic, technological, business, and policy perspectives to address contemporary sustainability challenges and advance the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
Guided by the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the journal seeks to maintain a transparent, rigorous, inclusive, and ethically responsible publication process.
Sustainexus — Connecting Disciplines. Advancing Sustainability.
Published by ABS Research Academy
“Academics for Better Society.”
13. Contact
For questions concerning peer review, editorial responsibilities, conflicts of interest, publication ethics, reviewer conduct, or editorial policies, please contact:
Editorial Office
Sustainexus: Interdisciplinary Research on Sustainability
Publisher: ABS Research Academy
Email: [email protected]
Journal Website: https://journals.absresearchacademy.com
Publisher Website: https://www.absresearchacademy.com

